| Ray Samuels Audio Emmeline SR-71
Headphone Amplifier |
| Can
You Take It With You? |
| |
|
June 2005 |
.jpg)
Come Fly
With Me
Many audiophiles, like travel enthusiasts,
love a good bargain. After all, it’s only a
natural human trait to want to fly First
Class—while paying Economy prices. Alas, real
life is more like this: pay Economy and find
yourself on a non-stop, 17.5 hour flight from
New York to Singapore. Ouch. That’s what was
waiting for me back in January—I make a trip
back to my native Singapore every year.
That’s when I had a stroke of inspiration:
what if I could take my listening room with
me?
Here’s what I was thinking…I already owned a
fourth generation 40GB iPod. Wouldn’t this be
the perfect opportunity to try it out with a
headphone amplifier and top-notch headphones?
And in the real world setting of a jetliner
cabin flying halfway across the world, no
less! Yes, we Stereo Timers will literally go
to the ends of the Earth for a review.
Preparing For Take-off
I first heard about Ray Samuels’ SR-71
headphone amp by lurking on headphone
enthusiast discussion forums like Head-Fi (www.headfi.org),
where it has impressed many a headphone geek.
The SR-71 is tiny, but fairly hefty for its
size (about the size of a pack of cigarettes).
It’s a dedicated portable headphone amp,
powered by two 9v batteries. The 1/8 –inch
thick faceplate is fairly utilitarian,
sporting a toggle switch for power, a metal
volume knob and two 1/8” minijacks for input
and output. Around back, two simple
hand-tightened screws secure the battery
compartment. Changing batteries takes all of
two minutes. The rest of the case work is
extruded aluminum and feels nice and solid in
your hand.
I wanted an appropriate headphone to take
along with me for my “real world” review—my
regular headphones, the Audio-Technica
ATH-W1000, were simply too bulky to bring on a
plane. I asked Ray Samuels himself for
suggestions and he immediately recommended the
Shure E5c—he loves their performance,
isolation and sheer bass output. That was good
enough for me. So, with iPod, SR-71 and E5c in
hand, I was ready to embark on my little
adventure. Fasten your seatbelts.
Flying
High: the SR-71 at 25,000 Feet
I may have been stuck in an Economy class
seat, but with my iPod hooked up to the SR-71
and the Shure E5c snugly lodged in my ear
canals, I was in total bliss. The SR-71/E5c
combo is a marriage made in heaven, or at
least as close as you can get to it at an
altitude of 25,000 feet. With the equivalent
of two full working days of seat time on my
hands, I tried this magical pairing with all
types of music and even with the in-flight
movies served up by Singapore Airlines. A word
about connections and set-up for all you iPod
users out there: I had my tunes compressed
with the Apple Lossless Encoder in order to
get as much music on my iPod as possible.
Uncompressed files would have limited the
number of albums I could take with me, but MP3
and AAC just don’t cut it in the quality
department for me. I also used the line-out
from the iPod dock, via a mini-jack cable made
from mil-spec silver wire, into the SR-71’s
1/8” input. This connection set-up extracts
the best possible sound from the iPod, because
the output from the headphone jack is just too
muddy and compressed sounding. There are, of
course, other ways to get the line-out from
the iPod without using the dock; two popular
choices are the SIK Din (www.sik.com) and
SendStation’s PocketDock with Lineout (www.sendstation.com).
I’ve never used my iPod with either of these,
so I can’t comment on their performance, but
thought I’d mention them anyway.
Now that all that set-up stuff’s out of the
way…
Before I actually played any music, I decided
to max out the volume on the SR-71 to see if I
could hear any noise. With the E5c, the SR-71
was silent as the tomb until the
third-from-last hash mark on the dial, where
low-level noise became audible. Unless you’re
deaf, or have a desire to be so, you shouldn’t
ever have the volume turned up that high (at
least not with a ’phone as sensitive as the
E5c.) But what of the music? Simply put, the
music just flowed. And as far as I could tell,
the SR-71 pulled no tricks in terms of
coloring the sound. What it did was impart the
full weight, body and slam inherent in every
track that I tried.
On Peter Wispelwey’s
Bach
Cello Suites [Channel Classics 12298], the
solo cello never sounded sweeter, particularly
on Track 1, the Prelude to Suite 1, which
happens to be one of my favorite pieces of
music. The SR-71 brilliantly retained all the
intimacy, detail and tone of Wispelwey’s
period instrument. When I took the SR-71 out
of the mix, the un-amplified sounds coming out
of the iPod seemed to drain all the life out
of the music—things just didn’t seem quite
there. This whole album is mic'
d pretty
closely and you can easily hear Wispelwey
breathing. The SR71/E5c combo made this
breathing amazingly clear and lifelike.
Because the E5c sits directly inside the ear
canal, I felt at times like the breaths I
heard were my own. You want to feel a
connection to your music and its artist? Well,
this is just about as close as you can get. In
fact, I sometimes unconsciously inhaled at the
same time Wispelwey does on the recording!
Before we leave Bach’s baroque music, let me
add that the lower registers of the cello on
this recording really demonstrated the bass
definition and extension that the SR-71 can
bring out. Bass notes didn’t just go deep—they
were tuneful and textured too. Simply
reproducing the lowest note on a recording is
not nearly good enough. The tone, tune and
rhythm of even the lowest notes are all there
with the SR-71, and with a performance like
Wispelwey’s, it would be criminal not to be
able to hear them in all their glory.
Moving on to more vocal-oriented music showed
me that the SR-71 isn’t just a bass-producing
monster. The critical midrange frequencies are
reproduced in a fluid, seamless way. Aimee
Mann, Patty Griffin and all my other favorite
female vocalists sounded like they had decided
to accompany me on my trip (shh! don’t tell my
wife!) The one attribute that kept cropping up
as I continued to listen? Intimacy. And this
was especially true with vocals, especially of
the female variety.
The SR-71 is so smooth in
the mids, so free of any grain or glare, that
voices just take on extra degree realism. Take
Patricia Barber, for instance. Her ‘live’
album, Companion [Blue Note 22963], has never
really been one of my favorites. But when I
listened to it this time (I have a giant
all-Patricia Barber play list on my iPod), I
was blown away. This time, the ‘live’ quality
of the album just seemed so real. Between the
details that I could hear in her voice—subtle
inflections, intonations and such—and the
quiet applause of the audience, I found myself
completely transported. When I tried listening
to Companion without the SR-71, the music
seemed dead by comparison, with all
dimensionality and subtle details flattened
out. Johnny Cash’s American IV: Man Comes
Around [Lost Highway 063339] is a
heartbreaking work, a final will and testament
from a giant of an artist who knows his time
is almost up. For the Johnny Cash fan, it’s
also pretty depressing. But the old
Man in
Black never shies away for one moment. As you
listen, you can hear the years in his voice,
the swaggering baritone now replaced by a
craggy quaver. The SR-71 draws out every
quiver, showing us the heart and soul that
Cash poured into this, is final studio album.
The effect is incredibly moving, perhaps even
more so than the first time I heard it on my
regular speaker-based system.
If you really want to hear the SR-71 blow you
away the first time you listen to it, I’d cue
up something with lots of drum work. Something
in the vein of Art Blakey’s
"Indestructible"
[Blue Note].
On track 2 of the album,
Mr. Jin,
the opening drum solo is nothing short of
amazing with the SR-71. You get fabulous
crescendos thanks to the dynamics that this
little battery-powered amp is able to conjure.
But on top of that, you also get every little
detail—each strike of stick on skin is clearly
articulated, with precise decays and delicious
tautness in the sound. There is no bloat, and
you get a real sense of the quickness of hand
necessary for such virtuoso work. Brilliant.
Back
down on earth
After enjoying more of the SR-71 on the return
leg of my flight, I sat down at home to try it
out with headphones other than the Shure E5c.
The line-up of cans included the E5c’s little
sibling, the E3c, my Audio-Technica ATH-W1000
and that old stand-by, the Grado SR60. Just
for laughs, I also tried the standard Apple
earbuds that came with my iPod. Let’s get the
last one out of the way, shall we? Bottom
line: nothing will help the sorry state of the
Apple earbuds. The SR-71 merely highlighted
just how bad these things are. On top of that,
I find them woefully uncomfortable as well.
The SR-71 is a minor-miracle of an amp, but it
still won’t transmutate garbage into gold.
Moving on, the E3c benefited hugely from the
SR-71. Although it costs less than half the
price of the E5c, these in-ears deliver close
to three-quarters of the performance. The
downside is that they are significantly more
difficult to drive. It’s ironic that these
relative cheapies almost demand an amplifier,
but there you go. The E3c also allowed me to
confirm that the sound of the SR-71 is more or
less neutral, with a balance that is neither
really warm nor cool. The E3c is a little thin
and much brighter in the highs that the
top-of-the-line E5c; the SR-71 helped a great
deal by adding weight, fullness and scale. On
the other hand, the SR60 didn’t seem to
benefit all that much from the SR-71. My chief
complaint with the SR-60 is that it just isn’t
a terribly detailed headphone. The sound is
pleasant enough, but it’s obvious that these
cans are a little dated by today’s standards.
I use them mainly at night with my home
theater set-up on nights when my wife is
turning in early. At home, my preferred
headphones are the ATH-W1000—they are easy to
drive, gorgeous to look at and provide a
smooth and open sound. The SR-71 and ATH-W1000
proved to be another winning partnership.
Together, the sounds they made were almost
exactly I would look for: tight and solid,
with a tuneful, textured presentation.
Returning to Wispelwey’s Bach cello suites, I
could clearly hear not just the strings, but
the also the woody body of the cello.
On hindsight, I’m glad that I started and
ended my serious listening with the Wispelwey
Bach recordings. I find well-recorded solo
classical music to be the best at grasping the
more subtle qualities in an amplifier. It’s
all too easy to be blown away by the scale and
dynamics that a good amp can bring to the
table—it’s lots of fun, which is probably it
makes sense to reach for music like that when
evaluating an amplifier’s performance. If all
you want is to make the music louder, then
just about any cheapie headphone amp will do.
But if you want amplification that also
illuminates, that takes you deeper and more
directly into the musical experience, then you
need the SR-71. At $395 a pop, the SR-71 is
definitively well within Economy class prices
for this hobby. But the performance it
delivers puts it—and you—among the rarefied
few that travel in First Class splendor.
Eujin Hong
___________
Price: $395
Company Information
Ray Samuels Audio
8005 Keeler
Skokie, IL 60076
Voice: (847)673-8739
E-mail:
rsaudio@raysamuelsaudio.com
Website:
www.raysamuelsaudio.com

|